Skip to content

Murder of Elizabeth Marriott

Also known as Lizzi Marriott

Dover · New Hampshire · United States · 2012 · 3 court cases

Every entry in this Murder of Elizabeth Marriott timeline links its source: court filings and rulings where they're public, and established news reporting where they aren't. The coverage below is hand-picked podcasts, documentaries, books and reporting about this case; we don't link to speculation videos.

Content note — This case involves an allegation or finding of sexual assault.

Current status

Convicted 27 Jun 2014Sentenced 14 Aug 2014: Life without parole

Last update: 13 Dec 2016 →
Newspaper clipping from The Boston Globe
The Boston Globe · View on Newspapers.com ↗

Get an email when something new happens in this case. Updates may be delayed — this is not live court monitoring.

At a glance

Victim

Elizabeth Marriott

When

9 Oct 2012

Current status

Convicted 27 Jun 2014 · Sentenced 14 Aug 2014: Life without parole

Trial verdict

27 Jun 2014 — Jury finds Mazzaglia guilty of first-degree murder

Sentence

14 Aug 2014 — Mazzaglia sentenced to life without parole

What happened

Elizabeth "Lizzi" Marriott was a 19-year-old from Westborough, Massachusetts, who loved the ocean and marine life.

She had volunteered at the New England Aquarium, and in autumn 2012 she began studying marine biology at the University of New Hampshire, living with family in Chester and working part-time at Target.

On 9 October 2012 she went to visit a co-worker, Kathryn McDonough, at the Dover apartment McDonough shared with Seth Mazzaglia, and did not come home.

Mazzaglia was arrested on 13 October 2012.

McDonough pleaded guilty in July 2013 to hindering the investigation and testified at his trial.

On 27 June 2014 a jury in Dover found Mazzaglia guilty of first-degree murder, and he was sentenced to life without parole.

Searchers never found Lizzi's body.

In 2016 the New Hampshire Supreme Court kept her private records sealed after her family objected, and upheld the conviction.

Where it happened

Dover, New Hampshire, United States

Full timeline

Source

Entries linked to a court, prosecutor, police, or government source.

Proceeding
Sort

Small dot: EntryOpen ring: MilestoneFilled ring: Verdict

  1. Oct 9 · Disappearance — investigation event

    Disappearance

  2. Oct 11 · Update — investigation event

  3. Oct 13 · Arrest — court event

    Arrest

  4. Pre-trialOct 15 · Hearing — court event

    Strafford County, New Hampshire
  5. Separate criminal caseDec 24 · Arrest — court event

    Arrest

    Rockingham County, New Hampshire
  6. Apr 10 · Charges filed · Formally charged — court event

    Charges filed

  7. Apr 18 · Charges filed · Formally charged — court event

    Charges filed

    Strafford County, New Hampshire
  8. Jul 25 · Plea — court event

    Plea

    Rockingham County, New Hampshire
  9. Sep 26 · Charges filed · Formally charged — court event

    Charges filed

    Strafford County, New Hampshire
  10. Nov 19 · Charges filed · Formally charged — court event

    Charges filed

  11. May 14 · Trial start — court event

    Trial start

  12. May 20 · Hearing — court event

  13. May 28 · Hearing — court event

  14. Jun 27 · Verdict — court event

    Verdict

  15. Oct 31 · Plea — court event

    Plea

  16. Nov 6 · Update — investigation event

  17. AppealJun 10 · Court ruling — court event

    Court ruling

  18. Jul 16 · Update — investigation event

  19. Sep 21 · Appeal — court event

    Appeal

  20. AppealSep 29 · Court ruling — court event

    Court ruling

  21. AppealNov 16 · Hearing — court event

  22. Concord Monitor

    Source clipping · 14 Dec 2016View on Newspapers.com

    AppealDec 13 · Court ruling — court event

    Court ruling

  23. Opinion · courts.nh.gov · New Hampshire Supreme Court · Court filing · Read court filing ↗
  24. Opinion · CourtListener · Strafford County Superior Court · Court filing · Read court filing ↗

What the source labels mean

Outside the record

Coverage

13 entries · podcast, documentary, website, article

Showing all 13 — Show less

Court record

2 cases: the 2012 charges ended in a guilty plea; and the 2016 appeal upheld the conviction.

Pre-trial · 20122 case numbers

Pleaded guilty31 Oct 2014

Mazzaglia pleads guilty to attempted escape and gets 3½ to 7 more years

State v. Seth Mazzaglia

Moved fromDover District Court
toStrafford County Superior Court, Dover219-2012-CR-00514

Strafford County, New Hampshire

Also filed in this case

Opinion · 13 Dec 2016

CourtListener13 Dec 2016

Timeline entries in this case (12)

Appeal · 20161 case number

Conviction upheld13 Dec 2016

NH Supreme Court unanimously affirms the conviction

State v. Seth Mazzaglia

New Hampshire Supreme CourtNew Hampshire2014-0592

Also filed in this case

Opinion · 13 Dec 2016

courts.nh.gov13 Dec 2016

Timeline entries in this case (6)Open the full record →

Separate criminal case · 20121 case number

Pleaded guilty25 Jul 2013

McDonough pleads guilty to the cover-up and is sentenced to serve 1½ to 3 years

State v. Kathryn McDonough

Rockingham County Superior Court, BrentwoodRockingham County, New Hampshire
Timeline entries in this case (3)

Questions

What was the latest development?

13 Dec 2016: Court ruling. Timeline entry

Follow this case

Get an email when something new happens in this case. Updates may be delayed — this is not live court monitoring.

Know a podcast, documentary, book or magazine about this case?

Record updated 16 Nov 2026